Prize-led Fundraising Benchmarking and Trends 2022

Webinar available to watch now, on-demand!

Watch Now

Getting the most out of email

Image showing email icon
Photo by Brett Jordon on Unsplash

We all rejoice when a donor provides their email address. There’s now a direct marketing link to our supporter at a fraction of the cost of mail. We have lots of lovely agile ways to amend content, create A/B tests and improve effectiveness during (rather than after) the campaign. Hooray!
Research has shown that email works best when part of a more integrated digital and non-digital campaign. So how do we make the most out of the email channel for your prize-led fundraising?

Email vs. mail attractiveness

First let’s look at some of the facts:

1. Opt-in email volumes remain relatively low
The number of charity supporters contactable by email almost doubled between 2018 and 2019 according to the Charity Benchmarks Sector Report 2019. As a percentage of the active supporter base of most charities, however, numbers remain relatively low at just 23%.

Chart showing percentage of total donors contactable by email (23%)
Chart showing percentage of donors contactable by channel

2. Mail is still dominant, but email is on the rise
In Royal Mail MarketReach / Kantar TNS 2017 research people said they engage with and value mail much more than email but that 49% have made an online transaction within the last 12 months.

Chart showing audience response to mail vs. email.
Chart showing audience response to mail vs. email

3. Recall is stronger with mail
The Royal Mail MarketReach Neuro-Insight report 2018 goes on to say that mail is 33% stronger than mail when it comes to engagement and 49% stronger for long-term memory encoding.

We’d suggest from the above research that email is not about to replace your mail campaigns in terms of response or volume. But it is increasing. So how can we maximise email effectiveness?

Prize-led fundraising perspective

We’re often asked whether a raffle or weekly lottery can work as an online only product. The answer will always be: ‘it depends’. It depends on your supporter base, your budget, your aspirations and, in the case of raffle especially, your prize and campaign duration. So while we’re not saying ‘no’, we would encourage a mixed-media approach.

You can see from the research that mail is still our biggest and best way to attract players – with more volume, more engagement and more recall. But that integrating this with a cohesive campaign across channels will drive even greater effectiveness. Following up a mailing with an email or targeted social media, for example, will stimulate recall from the mailing and provide an instant way to play without having to make the trip to the post box.

Channel is not the only consideration. We need to think about WHAT we are saying to people as well as WHERE we’re saying it.

Personalisation and segmentation

Personalisation and segmentation are high priorities here. You can read more about these in our recent blogs “Get to know your supporter personas for long-term benefits” and “The key to effective supporter journeys”.

Campaign Monitor explain in more detail relating to emails with the following top tips:

  1. Use the supporter’s name. A supporter is more likely to read an email that addresses them by name and it also promotes a sense of familiarity.
    This is a given, perhaps, on all supporter communications where possible. What else can we do to personalise more than just a salutation?
  2. Use a consistent sender name. By having a consistent sender name i.e. [email protected] rather than [email protected] means they feel like they’re speaking to someone rather than an entity.
    A great tip for all communications: people like to speak to people.
  3. Offer the opportunity to set preferences: encourage supporters to use these options to help you communicate more effectively with them.
    Do they want to be contacted by email only or by mail as well? Would they be interested in playing other games as part of their support? Are they interested in finding out more about your charitable work?
  4. Segment closely. What do you know about your supporters? How can you provide information that’s relevant to them based on what you know? Create smaller segments and constantly update based on new learnings.
    Segment against their motivations. Which players are only motivated by the prize? For which is the cause more of a draw and the prize a bonus? Easy tests can be formulated around prize and cause messaging to see which is more relevant to which supporters. This will help form messaging to these supporters both on and off-line.
  5. Automate. Rather than being impersonal, automation helps you respond to supporters according to their preferences and behaviours.
    Automation can work tremendously well for your prize-led supporters. Newly acquired supporters can receive emails telling the player more about the charity and your different fundraising products. What they chose to explore further will provide more information about their preferences and drive the next email communication. An effective email automation strategy can provide lots of additional insight about a supporter as well as help create loyalty with your charity.
  6. Call-to-action. Make it bold to encourage supporters to take a next step – whatever that might be.
    Finally, the call to action for prize-led fundraising will always be around ‘play now!’. But follow-up email calls-to-action can be around finding out more about your work, sharing with a friend or posting on social media.

Email benchmarks

Campaign Monitor have benchmarked charity emails against all other industries and we’re doing pretty well as a sector in getting people to open our emails but we’re losing them on the content and calls-to-action.

Chart showing non-profit email open rates vs. all industries according to Campaign Monitor research
Chart showing non-profit email open rates vs all industries

Keeping the information personal and relevant will help increase those click through rates and making the call to action really clear means there’s no ambiguity about what we’re asking of them.

Want to know more about how to build your prize-led fundraising across different channels?
At Woods Valldata we’re specialists in fundraising services and have been collaborating with our charity partners on their prize-led fundraising strategy for over 30 years. We have an in-house data strategy and insight team who are able to identify trends and opportunities within your data, a design studio to support your creative work and account directors dedicated to driving your programme forward.
Contact us now for more information about how we can support your charity fundraising.

Please share this blog...

« Back to articles